Chaos Corona Forum

Chaos Corona for 3ds Max => [Max] Bug Reporting => [Max] Resolved Bugs => Topic started by: Dippndots on 2018-07-27, 12:45:01

Title: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: Dippndots on 2018-07-27, 12:45:01

Subject Line pretty much says it all, when I use a .HDR HDRI in the override slots I get a ton of noise as seen in the image below. Compared to just making an 8-Bit JPG out of the same file and using that. Additionally it takes about 4x longer to render if I use the .HDR file.

I've tested this with a couple .HDR files. Anyone encountering this?

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: Frood on 2018-07-27, 14:22:53

You already started this one, haven't you?

https://forum.corona-renderer.com/index.php?topic=13104.0

Bugtracker:
https://corona-renderer.com/bugs/view.php?id=2124


Good Luck

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: Dippndots on 2018-07-27, 14:30:24

Oh wow, how embarrassing, I totally forgot about that... Feel free to delete this mods.

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: Frood on 2018-07-27, 14:45:03

Unfortunately moving or deleting topics does not fix the issue as we have seen :) It's still there to some extent and it is on my personal Corona-all-time-glitch-highscore table.


Good Luck

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: Dippndots on 2018-07-27, 14:48:04

You're right, just noticed that thread was moved to resolved bugs (presumably because it was replicable?)

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: Frood on 2018-07-27, 15:16:31

Maru registered the issue into the (public) bugtracker. To avoid duplicates, your thread was moved to "resolved".


Good Luck

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: Dream Think Lab on 2018-08-23, 17:57:57

Quote from: Frood on 2018-07-27, 15:16:31

Maru registered the issue into the (public) bugtracker. To avoid duplicates, your thread was moved to "resolved".

Has this been resolved though?  I am experiencing the same problem in Corona 2.  Insanely intense fireflies when using a different HDR in the reflection override slot than what I was using in the GI slot. 

...What I did find is that is I use the same HDR in both the GI and the override slot everything renders as expected.  I haven't tested this on any scene besides the current one I am working on.

See attached images.

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: Fluss on 2018-08-24, 11:34:24

Quote from: Frood on 2018-07-27, 14:45:03

it is on my personal Corona-all-time-glitch-highscore table.

Same here, this is one of the most annoying bugs for now. Sometimes I really don't understand how things are prioritized... We now it's broken for ages, come on guys! please!

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: Alexandre Besson on 2018-08-24, 11:58:52

+1

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: pokoy on 2018-08-24, 16:41:24

Same here. Also, I feel like this problem hasn't been as visible with earlier version and started to be harder to get rid of since 1.5 or so. Yes, please fix some of these long standing issues.

Title: Re: Crazy noise when using an .HDR as reflections override
Post by: maru on 2018-08-27, 12:50:09

It is not solved yet, but it is logged in our internal tracker with a good description and examples, and is planned to be fixed as a part of a larger overhaul. No timeframe yet. 
The thing is that such "light transport" problems are extremely hard to fix - it requires a lot of work and caution not to break some other things.