Chaos Corona Forum

General Category => General CG Discussion => Hardware => Topic started by: blank... on 2016-08-10, 00:12:19

Title: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: blank... on 2016-08-10, 00:12:19
I don't know if things changed, if I remember correctly Max didn't like non Nvidia cards in the past. I'm not using iray.
Thanks in advance!
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: Ludvik Koutny on 2016-08-10, 00:30:49
I wouldn't risk it, AMD has a long history of shitty drivers. Also, from my experience, AMD GPUs that have more or less same performance as their nVidia counterparts in games have usually worse performance in 3ds Max for some reason. If you have exactly the money to afford RX 470 then get the best nVidia GPU that money can buy ;)
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: blank... on 2016-08-10, 00:34:23
Yup, it's pretty much new RX 470 or used GTX 970.
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: Ludvik Koutny on 2016-08-10, 09:43:48
GTX970 all the way... if you don't mind 0.5GB eaten by a dog :)
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: romullus on 2016-08-10, 10:25:10
I had similar decision to make recently. I saw some users on the russian forums had praise recent radeon cards as better choise for max, but what put me off, was the fact that rx470/480 draws about 5 times more power than nvidia counterparts on idle in multi monitor setup. For me that was more than enough to make my mind in favor of geforce. Never had radeon before and it looks like that won't change for few more years - ordered new card just yesterday :]
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: blank... on 2016-08-10, 10:36:25
if you don't mind 0.5GB eaten by a dog :)

Yea, I sorta do mind, but it looks like Nvidia will be the final choice. I'm considering learning Unreal Engine, so more VRAM the better. I don't game and am perfectly happy with current GTX 650 to be honest :)

... but what put me off, was the fact that rx470/480 draws about 5 times more power than nvidia counterparts on idle in multi monitor setup.

So this is true, I also saw the numbers but thought it's under some special circumstances. Well, to the ebay it is!

Quote
ordered new card just yesterday :]

So you're the one that oudbid me on that GTX 980! Damn you, damn you to hell! :D
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: romullus on 2016-08-10, 11:07:25
Quote
ordered new card just yesterday :]

So you're the one that oudbid me on that GTX 980! Damn you, damn you to hell! :D

Nah, i couldn't afford such card and even if i could, i'd go with 1060 :]
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: Ludvik Koutny on 2016-08-10, 12:35:16
Yeah... actually romullus is right...  Why don't you go with 1060? :)
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: blank... on 2016-08-10, 12:45:00
970 cca. 200€, 1060 cca. 300€
And I refuse to go down the "if you add just a little more you can get..." road. Been there, done that, before you know it your buying something twice as expensive then you planed on :D
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: burnin on 2016-08-10, 14:10:51
In short:
Viewport wise, Max prefers DirectX, here's where nVidia GTX is best.
970 is fine (you can also play with FStorm and IRay).

Edit: EVGA Sale (US, Canada, Mexico) (http://www.evga.com/Products/ProductList.aspx?type=8)
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: blank... on 2016-09-29, 23:51:58
And I refuse to go down the "if you add just a little more you can get..." road. Been there, done that, before you know it your buying something twice as expensive then you planed on :D

Sigh....
Title: Re: Would 3dsmax work OK with RX 470?
Post by: Juraj on 2016-09-30, 00:22:09
good choice ;- )