Chaos Corona Forum
Chaos Corona for 3ds Max => [Max] Feature Requests => [Max] Resolved Feature Requests => Topic started by: musashidan on 2015-05-29, 19:38:43
-
It would be great if there was a way to integrate a PBR shader, or even an implementation into the standard CoronaMTL with a Metallic map slot and some way to convert the maps exported from a program like Substance Painter. There are workarounds to match the SP look with some shuffling around of different maps but it's a pain in the arse.
Because you can texture high-poly assets in SP by using AO and Curvature maps I think a PBR implementation would be great in Corona, and I'm sure it's only a matter of time before most renderers incorporate one. (I think MAYA 2016 added a native PBR shader)
And just to clarify: when I say PBR I mean a metallic/roughness Disney BDRF shader.
-
+1
-
+1, was mentionned as 1.6 feature some times ago but it's has been overlooked
-
We can already get a PBR shader using Corona and SP. Check out the results in this thread:
https://forum.corona-renderer.com/index.php/topic,16525.0.html
-
I'd say it's a workaround, so it's not optimal. And it was meant to be a more general shader like disney's one or alsurface shader. With metallic/roughness workflow as it's start to be the new standard. So it would be nice to have such a shader in one of the upcoming release. But yeah, it's not top priority.
Btw, I would not make a dedicated skin shader as planned on the roadmap. Alsurface completely suit the needs for that kind of stuff :
http://www.anderslanglands.com/alshaders/tut_skin1.html
Best of both worlds imho. Powerfull, versatile. The only thing alshader miss is the sheen parameter.
What's more, it support cryptomatte :
http://www.anderslanglands.com/alshaders/tut_cryptomatte.html
-
I wonder if metallic-roughness shader implementation for off-line renderers is free from disease that real-time renderers suffers from, where transition between metalic and non-metallic surfaces looks very ugly? If not, then why we need such inferior shader?
-
What you are talking about is ralated to the texel density of the UVs of the texture used to blend metallic and non-metallic parts. And it appear also in specular/glossiness workflow, it's just less noticeable coz the effect is reversed (black instead of white). It's also highly dependant of the resolution, which is mostly a real-time problem, as texel density. Many offline renders use the metallic/roughness workflow with no issue so i don't know how it could be considered "inferior".
-
I'd say it's a workaround, so it's not optimal.
It's not a work around, this set up is by every definition a PBR shader setup. The only thing it is missing is a neat little container to put it in.
-
As far as I remember the new Physical Material introduced in 2017 has a simple mode with metalness/roughness setup, I always thought it would work fine with Corona and was the reason there's no dedicated PBR shader coming with it.
-
I'd say it's a workaround, so it's not optimal.
It's not a work around, this set up is by every definition a PBR shader setup. The only thing it is missing is a neat little container to put it in.
By workaround, I meant it introduce unwanted workflow. Modern "uber" shaders (dysney, alsurface..) are good in that way. They allow to reproduce almost every materials (except hair) within one node.
As far as I remember the new Physical Material introduced in 2017 has a simple mode with metalness/roughness setup, I always thought it would work fine with Corona and was the reason there's no dedicated PBR shader coming with it.
I think it's a really bad idea to rely on autodesk's stuff.
-
So if a developer goes through here, can you share your thoughts for choosing to make a dedicated skin shader over an uber shader ?
-
So if a developer goes through here, can you share your thoughts for choosing to make a dedicated skin shader over an uber shader ?
you mean why is skin shader not part of single universal shader, or why feature X was implemented before feature Y?
-
i mean why is skin shader not part of single universal shader.
-
done