Personal interior

[AnubisMe]

As much as I like doing exterior work here is a interior I designed.

CC welcome

[AnubisMe]

no comments?

[Geezer]

Hi,

1. Lighting looks flat / light side - shadow side?

2. Too much yellow tint from bounced light

3. Textures / shaders are also too simple

4. Composition cloud be better if you want to stay with a 1pp image.

5. Too much variation going on with the plants

6. work more on the styling

I know it is a wip image but these were the things I observed.
Hope you dont mind and will be able to push the scene further.

[maru]

Well, honestly, it doesn't look very bad and doesn't look very good. Lighting isn't bad. When you unzoom it looks ok. Now about the flaws:
-looks like you used displacement on the chimney bricks, it looks like the side faces are detached from the rest of it
-the fire doesn't look good... it's too dark and contrasty and lacks transparency
-the area where palm leaves are against very bright background - not sure if it's image compression but it looks too "crispy"
-the image looks slightly overexposed but it's ok if it's intended
-ugly (low res) background image

[fire3d]

Overall, nice room, for a better look:

Plants lookin ..... äh ..... dunno, there's no life in the plants, the plant pot's have no "feeling - Window frames are a little bit to shiny,
the stonewall looks way to flat, also the fireplace is not deep enough, the look out of the windows is to clear
and to bright

otherwise a nice idea/concept

[AnubisMe]

Thanks guys, this is exactly the type of feedback I am looking for.

[AnubisMe]

I should also note that that this is my own design, so I don't have a team of interior designers, architects etc helping me out for this :)