Messages

1

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-17, 20:50:57 »

What issues exactly? Several people already demonstrated in this topic that you can get identical or nearly identical renders in both programs, given the fact that the scenes are prepared as close as possible to each other. No offence, but i think the only issue here is the user error.

The problems I mentioned are minor settings differences between the two applications.

I stated that minimizing the differences between them creates awareness.

2

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-16, 18:34:08 »

I think this issue raises awareness about correcting these deficiencies in corona in the future.

Thank you everyone for your answers.

3

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-14, 13:48:39 »

I believe some differences may be expected when rendering the same assets in different host apps or render engines. For example, bump value 0.7 could mean something else in Max than in C4D.
I'll check with the devs and will return to you once I have any answers.
Can you tell me which exact version of Corona for Max and C4D you are using? I couldn't find this information in this thread.

I use Corona 11 Hotfix 1 versions in both applications.

4

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-13, 15:26:01 »

https://cdn.knightlab.com/libs/juxtapose/latest/embed/index.html?uid=9b958248-ca7b-11ee-9ddd-3f41531135b6

5

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-12, 18:40:21 »

Could the authorities be interested in us finding a solution to the problem?

6

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-11, 21:31:29 »

I would also like to point out this.

There is no difference in material settings in both applications.

This is the result when I use 255 white light.

I'm sorry it took me this long to respond :(

7

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-11, 18:35:34 »

Material settings are like this

8

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-11, 17:48:52 »

Thank you for your patience.

I recreated the scenes and tried to make them similar.

I share the results with you.

I would also like to point out this.
Materials, lights etc. I did everything using corona.
I did not use materials from Vray.

I did not change any settings of 3ds Max and Cinema 4d, they are the original settings.
I think the problem is caused by the poor specifications of my computer and the limitations of the applications (3ds-c4d).

9

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-11, 14:43:36 »

I will share all the details after recreating the scenes. Stay tuned, thank you.

10

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-11, 14:32:05 »

I would like to point out that I didn't record the scenes because I did it for testing purposes, but I may do it again if I'm wrong.

11

[Max] General Discussion / Re: 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-11, 14:20:58 »

What I'm comparing is that the texture quality and appearance differs between applications even though I use the same material library.

12

[Max] General Discussion / 3ds Max vs Cinema 4d Comparison

« on: 2024-02-11, 14:10:46 »

Hello everyone

First of all, I have been using Corona via 3ds max for a long time and I would like to mention a few things I have experienced.

Recently, while browsing a model sales page, I saw very nice rendering photos and wanted to examine the profile of the person who made them. Frankly, I was surprised because we were both using corona render, but my renders were not even close to his renders.

When I looked into it a little more, I realized that it was using corona through Cinema 4d and I wanted to focus on that and try it.

(I would like to say that there are minor differences in lighting and camera settings, but I don't think much will change)

I wanted to share the results with you and the corona team.