Yes giving opinion is valuable thing but i think that there is difference if someone is saying something in manner "it is ok, but it needs a lot more work" I am just saying that this type of commenting started to be more often then it should.
Constructive critique?
Juraj please before you start doing "i know this guy" routine... Maybe someone doesn't know who DIA is and i am glad that i know now how good he is and that he is one of the best out there etc.
I have clearly stated that this is not about if he CAN or CAN NOT do better... It is just how he critique this, it is even more important when you know something better to share that in adequate manner instead putting your nose up like bunch of people that are good in their business these days(didn't say he done that)
Just talking from general point of view of people who are so up high that they forgot they were once at start... no matter how talented person is or hard working no one wouldn't benefit from such vague comment.
I think that your lines dropped here are in pilot phase, and they need more work. How that sounds pretty constructive isn't it? cmon
I didn't tell you or DIA or anyone for that matter something like "You should work on realism little more" that is vague same as telling someone on karaoke night "you should sing little more like David Bowie and you should also write your own stuff" and for 99% people that is here probably cuz of you or DIA or anyone else that is really good in this job not very respectful and pretty lame(from such wizards as you are)
As i mentioned earlier that is just conversational decency, if you are not able or you do not know how to give constructive(serving a useful purpose; tending to build up) criticism please do not give lame one "it could be more real" as you just gonna shit on other peoples hard work and your wizard shit tend to be more heavy then from unknown guy as me as you are best in this business. That is the attitude, yes i did overreact and i did want to overreact as i wouldn't be able to drop continuation to my original post and in no way you would even notice that post.
So before you think that i think that your work is shit, i don't! I don't have anything else about you to say as i do not care even if you are devil, i don't know you and you are not my friend but if i do participate in this forum it is not as i want to accept your BS critique by default, and i am not defending author as he can speak for himself also i am not his friend nor do i know him but usually when lines are dropped as "it should be more real" forum starts to lose it's purpose... And year or two or 5 years from now people start telling "That was good forum few years back" And how many forums you know that are like that...
And yes i do care about reputation but i do accept the fact that i am human and that i can be total jackass, that i have same as every other person conciseness, jealousy and every bad shit you can think of...
But since you are thinking that critique like "it should be more realistic" is good(as you value his opinion) here it is what you wrote...
"I do not like it either, it's technically nice but I find the mood not fitting, it's far too monotone even for restricted palette." <----do you see any difference...
And stating that DIA is being malicious is more in affect and how fed up from that type of comments i could be(same as with BRAVO type) but at least kind words work better then shit ones...
And once again anyone should express line of thoughts and once again clap clap to your work(Juraj, DIA) nothing personal.
DIA i didn't know anything about you and now that i do, your comment is even more out of the line... And i am glad that you stopped and take notice on my remark to your comment, it's just my compliment to your work(that is great!) and bed commenting.
